Quick Test: MTs vs. Bike Break Cable
-
Thanks for those tests, Beat.

...
SPIRIT
Being mocked for its "inferior" wirecutters I think it did perform best (although the difference to the Re-Charge is marginal). Because I think the difference between Surge and Re-Charge might be due to manufacturing tolerance I tested two more Spirits (I don't have more Surges, Charges, Waves or MP-600). Both of those Spirits showed the same result as the first one, cutting the break-cable effortlessly.Not surprised one bit.
You misread the "inferior" wirecutters comments. The Spirit and Swisstool are excellent wire cutters for hard wire, fencing wire, ... anything heavy duty. Where they fail is at cutting soft, stranded wire.Thanks for the attitude adjustment (wow, that is an obscure movie reference, ten points for house MT.O if you get it :P).
Dazed and Confused?

The #1 enemy of the state is Edgar Friendly... Solid '90s action... lots of stars (Stallone, Snipes, Bullock)
-
@Etherealicer said:
The #1 enemy of the state is Edgar Friendly... Solid '90s action... lots of stars (Stallone, Snipes, Bullock)Demolition Man... Nice film.

-
Good work, E.

Was spannering one of my bikes tonight and thought I'd add my findings. Dug out a few multis and some brake cable to test - all ones that I feel would work in a bike tool kit, so the SwissTool is out. Got a Spirit, Rebar, Wave, MP400, Crunch and my new SwitchPlier 2. Also used my Park Tool cable cutters as a benchmark
First up, Park Tool CN-10

Very good clean cut, easy to grip and not a lot of force needed. No frayed ends.Next, SOG SwitchPlier 2.0

Disappointing. Didn't cut through and very hard on my hands when squeezing tight.Leatherman Crunch

Also disappointing. Didn't cut through, cable splayed sideways and got jammed between the jaws.Leatherman Wave

Didn't cut through on the first, second or third cut, eventually got it on the 4th. Frayed the ends, generally made a meal of it but did the job eventually.Gerber MP400

Very surprising, this one - I wasn't expecting much, but it cut through cleanly and easily on the first try. No frayed ends!Victorinox Spirit

Cut through first try but not as clean a cut as the Gerber. Expected better.Leatherman Rebar

The first cut I tried slipped out of the end of the cutters and one strand was left attached. I tried again, making sure the cable was held in place and this time got a good, if slightly uneven, cut. Uncomfortable to grip - the Wave was better.I also had a delivery of 2.2mm and 2.5mm brass rod today and needed to cut it up for storage. All of the pliers except the SwitchPlier handled the 2.5mm rod with ease - the SwitchPlier only got about 1/3 of the way through and I had to bend the rod to finish. All of them worked just fine on the 2.2mm, and I know from experience that the Spirit and Rebar both cut 3mm brass rod easily.
-
Wow!!! Great tests, thank guys!!!

-
@hiraethus said:
Good work, E.
Was spannering one of my bikes tonight and thought I'd add my findings. Dug out a few multis and some brake cable to test - all ones that I feel would work in a bike tool kit, so the SwissTool is out. Got a Spirit, Rebar, Wave, MP400, Crunch and my new SwitchPlier 2. Also used my Park Tool cable cutters as a benchmark
First up, Park Tool CN-10

Very good clean cut, easy to grip and not a lot of force needed. No frayed ends.Next, SOG SwitchPlier 2.0

Disappointing. Didn't cut through and very hard on my hands when squeezing tight.Leatherman Crunch

Also disappointing. Didn't cut through, cable splayed sideways and got jammed between the jaws.Leatherman Wave

Didn't cut through on the first, second or third cut, eventually got it on the 4th. Frayed the ends, generally made a meal of it but did the job eventually.Gerber MP400

Very surprising, this one - I wasn't expecting much, but it cut through cleanly and easily on the first try. No frayed ends!Victorinox Spirit

Cut through first try but not as clean a cut as the Gerber. Expected better.Leatherman Rebar

The first cut I tried slipped out of the end of the cutters and one strand was left attached. I tried again, making sure the cable was held in place and this time got a good, if slightly uneven, cut. Uncomfortable to grip - the Wave was better.I also had a delivery of 2.2mm and 2.5mm brass rod today and needed to cut it up for storage. All of the pliers except the SwitchPlier handled the 2.5mm rod with ease - the SwitchPlier only got about 1/3 of the way through and I had to bend the rod to finish. All of them worked just fine on the 2.2mm, and I know from experience that the Spirit and Rebar both cut 3mm brass rod easily.
Thanks for chipping in.
Appears that the replaceable wire-cutters on the MP-600 are not a benefit for every task. I should soon have one without too, so I will probably extend my test.
-
I love these kinds of tests :D :D
-
@Etherealicer said:
Thanks for chipping in.Appears that the replaceable wire-cutters on the MP-600 are not a benefit for every task. I should soon have one without too, so I will probably extend my test.
My pleasure.
I think the same of the replaceable cutters on the Rebar - definitely an advantage for some situations (hard wire, serviceability) but have disadvantages too (reduced gripping area, complexity, only come on a plier head with coarse teeth).
-
@enki_ck said:
Thanks for those tests, Beat.
...
SPIRIT
Being mocked for its "inferior" wirecutters I think it did perform best (although the difference to the Re-Charge is marginal). Because I think the difference between Surge and Re-Charge might be due to manufacturing tolerance I tested two more Spirits (I don't have more Surges, Charges, Waves or MP-600). Both of those Spirits showed the same result as the first one, cutting the break-cable effortlessly.Not surprised one bit.
You misread the "inferior" wirecutters comments. The Spirit and Swisstool are excellent wire cutters for hard wire, fencing wire, ... anything heavy duty. Where they fail is at cutting soft, stranded wire.Yea, but the scissors work great on that sort of wire

Actually I was surprised at the great Spirit result and anything but good Surge result. Still in both tests the Rebar pliers worked good, so what gives?
-
I didn't test the Surge, so I can only assume it was operator error. ;)
-
@hiraethus said:
I didn't test the Surge, so I can only assume it was operator error. ;)
-
I didn't test the Surge, so I can only assume it was operator error. ;)

Ok, I have to step in here, you need to come up with a better insult, I mean seriously I have already done that:
How did the Surge go with the handle side stranded-wire cutters?

Didn't think of that (Surge noob)
So, you have until tomorrow to come up with a better quip!
-
I had to cut some bike cable today and figured since the MP400 did so well in your test I would give it a try. My MP400 would not even cut and just folded in between the cutters. Complete failure. The Rebar had to finish it off and got through it, but did not perform very well either.
-
@captain spaulding said:
I had to cut some bike cable today and figured since the MP400 did so well in your test I would give it a try. My MP400 would not even cut and just folded in between the cutters. Complete failure. The Rebar had to finish it off and got through it, but did not perform very well either.Interesting, you having problems with the Rebar, that one worked well for me. Was yours new or well used?
-
@captain spaulding said:
I had to cut some bike cable today and figured since the MP400 did so well in your test I would give it a try. My MP400 would not even cut and just folded in between the cutters. Complete failure. The Rebar had to finish it off and got through it, but did not perform very well either.
Interesting, you having problems with the Rebar, that one worked well for me. Was yours new or well used?
The Rebar has seen use, but not a whole lot of pliers use. Probably the first use of the wire cutters on it. Same with the MP400.
-
Those knipex pliers would be a great addition to my toolbox :)
-
nice testing! very informative.
-
@captain spaulding said:
@captain spaulding said:
I had to cut some bike cable today and figured since the MP400 did so well in your test I would give it a try. My MP400 would not even cut and just folded in between the cutters. Complete failure. The Rebar had to finish it off and got through it, but did not perform very well either.
Interesting, you having problems with the Rebar, that one worked well for me. Was yours new or well used?
The Rebar has seen use, but not a whole lot of pliers use. Probably the first use of the wire cutters on it. Same with the MP400.
Here is one of those silly ideas, could the Rebar and Surge issues be related to the removable wire cutters?
-
@captain spaulding said:
@captain spaulding said:
I had to cut some bike cable today and figured since the MP400 did so well in your test I would give it a try. My MP400 would not even cut and just folded in between the cutters. Complete failure. The Rebar had to finish it off and got through it, but did not perform very well either.
Interesting, you having problems with the Rebar, that one worked well for me. Was yours new or well used?
The Rebar has seen use, but not a whole lot of pliers use. Probably the first use of the wire cutters on it. Same with the MP400.
Here is one of those silly ideas, could the Rebar and Surge issues be related to the removable wire cutters?
Yes, no, maybe... except the Surge also had problems when using the handle side stranded-wire cutters. I hope its not the case but I suspect it might be manufacturing tolerance, that leads to this result.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
