Shootout- Leatherman Skeletool vs SOG Reactor
-
@MTMatt said:
Thanks Def for "testing" the bottle opener.
It seems more important on this side of the pond (no screw caps here)
But does the SOG one work ok?
If you are opening a few beverages at a time it is more than adequate. If you are a professional bartender in a fancy disco and open hundreds of bottles every hour then I suggest getting a better bottle opener than either the Skeletool or the Reactor. :P
The Skeletool pulls the cap off the bottle first time, every time. The Reactor may get first pull every time with some practice, but I'd say at least half the time you will need to do two lifts per cap. The Reactor is functional enough, but not even close to ideal, but I suppose that could be said about just about any function on just about any multitool.
Def
-
@Wspeed said:
I still worry about the flat bit holder it's on a small size pivot screw
So I can't see it lasting long on heavy duty screws ( stubborn screws)
Something is going to give at some point

I have been using my Skeletool for many years now. I have worn out two going on three #2 Philips bits getting after some stubborn and stuck screws with it over the years and my pliers joints are still very tight. It may look delicate but the hinge joint at the pliers have proven to be very robust in my experience. YMMV
-
I still worry about the flat bit holder it's on a small size pivot screw
So I can't see it lasting long on heavy duty screws ( stubborn screws)
Something is going to give at some point

I have been using my Skeletool for many years now. I have worn out two going on three #2 Philips bits getting after some stubborn and stuck screws with it over the years and my pliers joints are still very tight. It may look delicate but the hinge joint at the pliers have proven to be very robust in my experience. YMMV
That's great mcb

That sounds good makes me more at ease
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
@MTMatt said:
Thanks Def for "testing" the bottle opener.
It seems more important on this side of the pond (no screw caps here)
But does the SOG one work ok?
If you are opening a few beverages at a time it is more than adequate. If you are a professional bartender in a fancy disco and open hundreds of bottles every hour then I suggest getting a better bottle opener than either the Skeletool or the Reactor. :P
The Skeletool pulls the cap off the bottle first time, every time. The Reactor may get first pull every time with some practice, but I'd say at least half the time you will need to do two lifts per cap. The Reactor is functional enough, but not even close to ideal, but I suppose that could be said about just about any function on just about any multitool.
Def
Thanks Grant for your feedback

-
as a side note,
I think the Skele should get some points for having a second carry method via carabiner, as I've hung it from the belt loops more than once in some less than ideal situations. Alo applicable to MOLLEs, backpacks and other packs/bags

But the Reactor should also have some reward for having a blade without holes in it. I've had stuff getting inside my Skele's holes more than once, resulting in gunk and evn rust (yeah I forgot to see the dirt and wash it out of the hole for some time) when delaying the cleaning.

Also, the Skele's holes and alien looking curves allow for much pocket lint and dust to fill those voids, I don't know how the Reactor's construction would fare with that
-
Funny you should mention Carry Methods, as that is the subject of Part 6 of this series, and the second last installment!
Part 6- Carry Methods

Another big strength of the Skeleool is its versatility in carry- it can be clipped onto a pack or other equipment or clipped to a pocket using the pocket clip. Conversely the Reactor can really only be carried clipped to a pocket

Comparing pocket clip to pocket clip to keep them on an even playing field, the Skeletool pocket clip is longer than the one on the Reactor, and generally that translates to a more secure hold in the pocket. However, the Reactor pocket clip allows the Reactor to ride much lower in your pocket, and the fact that it is shorter is offset by the fact that the tool itself is shorter.

Instead on this one I think I am going to call it a draw, as the clip is far better on the Reactor than the one on the Skeletool, but the Skeletool offers us twice as many carry options, both of which are highly effective.

Like I did with the screwdrivers, I think I am going to have to rule this one a tie, not because they are the same, but because the Reactor is superior, but the range of options provided by the Skeletool is undeniable.
SCORE- SOG 5, Leatherman 4
There's one event left and so far SOG has maintained the lead! Will they keep it? Will Leatherman tie it up? Only one way to find out! Tune in tomorrow for the finale- same multitool time, same multitool channel! :D
Def
-
Nice write up look forward to tomorrow

-
Not that I would buy one of these...

-
Waiting for the last post! :)

-
Sorry, I got distracted by some other stuff... more on that later.... >:D
I will get the last part posted shortly.

Def
-
Part 7- Overall Fit and Finish
This one is also immediately apparent as soon as you handle each one- The Leatherman Skeletool just feels nicer in the hand, and each of it’s functions is crisp and locks into place. There’s nothing wrong with the SOG per se, it just doesn’t seem to feel as solid.

When you fold the Skeletool blade out you feel a healthy bit of resistance- it’s smooth, but you know it’s not going to fall out accidentally, and then when the liner lock snaps into place it feels like a bank vault door closing. The relatively deep click you heard when it does fills you with confidence that this tool is going to be as strong as you need it and won’t give in easily.
By comparison, although the blade setup is much different, the Reactor’s blade flings open like a kid tossing his backpack on the couch when coming in the house after school, and the liner lock is more of a pop than a click. Not a bad thing in its own right, but it just doesn’t give you that confident feeling that you get from the Skeletool.

Going a bit further, at some points it seems like someone spent more time crafting the Skeletool, with it’s sweeping lines and many interlocking parts, while the Reactor feels like someone was just trying to put the most used functions together to get something made. There’s nothing wrong with that mentality, and in fact I prefer a feature rich and functional tool over one that sacrifices function for the sake of looks, but the Skeletool hasn’t really sacrificed much for the way it looks.
The screwdrivers are a great example of this- the way the screwdriver end folds neatly inside the split end of the carabiner (unless you are using the flat bit!) and the spare bit tucks neatly into an otherwise unused spot on the frame, while the bit on the Reactor just sort of fits into a spare end because it can’t stay in the bit driver when not in use. The attention to detail shows that the Skeletool designer Glenn Klecker really put some effort into it.
In my opinion, the Skeletool design does qualify as art, because Leatherman continues to use that concept with the MUT, Signal and other tools, and yet they just don’t have the same appeal as the Skeletool, kind of like if someone stuck a bag of Ruffles in the hands of the Mona Lisa.
What all this means is that Leatherman has gotten this last point, and once again a shootout has resulted in a tie. It’s a bit of a shock to me as well, as once again my personal bias has been well established, but in the end each one has its strengths and weaknesses, and, as with any multitool, has its compromises. In the end though I have to say that I just don’t think you can go wrong with either of these tools. Yes, the Skeletool is higher quality, but the Reactor has massive pliers, well able to tackle big jobs despite being in a smaller package.And, there’s a twist….
In an ultra secret memo that I may be “sanctioned” for spilling, SOG has recognized the quality issues that have been plaguing them lately and have informed me that they are making an increase in quality a huge priority. This is great news for any SOG enthusiast, and I am looking forward to seeing what the result is. Maybe I’ll revisit this in a year or so, with a new Skeletool and a new Reactor and find out for ourselves!
Congratulations to both tools, and both companies- you have both made a fine tool, and, in the end, isn’t that really what everyone here wants, regardless of where it came from?
FINAL SCORE- Leatherman 5, SOG 5
TIE TIE TIE TIE TIE TIE TIE TIE TIE TIE TIE TIE :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
Def
-
Great review!

The downside is that it just made me want the Skele even more, haha. -
That was a great write up
Hope we get some more soon

-
Love it!

-
@Wspeed said:
That was a great write up
Hope we get some more soon

The difficulty is trying to find two tools that are close in the same functions. For example, if you tried comparing the Wave and the Spirit, well, you just can't do it because the Wave has one handed opening blades, putting it in a totally different category than the Spirit. If you need one handed opening blades then the Wave wins. If you want better construction and more functions then the Spirit wins. You really have to look to find two tools that are on the same level and have all the same features, otherwise there's no real comparison.
But, I'm happy having the options we have available to us. :D
Def
-
Terrific write up and comparison. Thank you for the work you put into it.

-
Well done as always!

-
I really enjoyed this thread!

-
@Aloha007 said:
Terrific write up and comparison. Thank you for the work you put into it.
It was absolutely my pleasure.
It's easy to say you like this more than that, but I really want to know why. Unless it is made by Taylor Cutlery, no tool is a complete waste. Even the worst tools (except Taylor Cutlery products) have redeeming qualities, and it is worth looking for them- not that I think either of these tools are anywhere near the worst. I very much like both of them, and they have both seen a significant amount of carry and use.
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




