Skip to content
Collapse
? [[global:guest]]
Unread Recent
HOME SEARCH PROFILE MESSAGES 0 BOOKMARKS MEMBERS BADGES
Multitool.Org Forum
MultiTool.org • Community Header Space • Watch This Space

Shootout- Leatherman Skeletool vs SOG Reactor

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved General Tool Discussion
96 Posts 1 Posters 21.7k Views
  1. Home
  2. Tool Talk
  3. General Tool Discussion
  4. Shootout- Leatherman Skeletool vs SOG Reactor
Shootout- Leatherman Skeletool vs SOG Reactor
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • Nix Offline
    Nix
    Posts: 24,263
    Nix Offline
    Nix
    wrote on last edited by
    #67 Quote Reply

      I really enjoyed this thread! :salute:

      Merit Badges
      Hook User ALOX with Scissors ALOX Colors Level 3 The Pioneer X Challenge Camo SAK Birth Year SAK Minimal SAK Challenge Sporkman Paracord LM Rebar Challenge MTO Tool MTo Store User Zip Tie User Victorinox Spirit Challenge EDC Pocket Dump Challenge Santa 111mm SAK Challenge Fire Making OCD Squad Scale Changer Buck 110 Challenge Buck User Mod User 111mm Collector Level 1 SAKMC Fishing SOG Power Challenge Axe User Chuck Yeager Challenge Outdoor Cook LM Wave Challenge The Huntsman Challenge Titanium Mora User SAK STACK Challenge 30 Days Fixed Blade Challenge Toothpick User The SUPER Challenge Hacker Traditional Folder Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge 30 Day Axe Challenge PST 30 Day Challenge Chili Award Buck 112 Ranger 30 Day Challenge Fieldmaster 30 Day Challenge Victorinox SwissTool Challenge Soldier 30 Day Challenge 30 Blades 30 Days Spyderco 30 Day Challenge The Nessmuk Challenge Skeletool 30 Day Challenge 30 day EDC Challenge Poker Face Challenge Farmer X Challenge Gas Station MRE challenge 30 day challenge - 58, 65 and 74mm SAKs GEC Challenge SAK STACK Challenge 60 Days Delemont 30 Day Challenge Soldier On 90 Day Challenge Pen Challenge
      1 Reply Last reply
      • Grant Lamontagne Offline
        Grant Lamontagne
        administrators
        Posts: 67,999
        Grant Lamontagne Offline
        Grant Lamontagne
        administrators
        wrote on last edited by
        #68 Quote Reply

          @Aloha007 said:
          Terrific write up and comparison. Thank you for the work you put into it. :like:

          It was absolutely my pleasure.

          It's easy to say you like this more than that, but I really want to know why. Unless it is made by Taylor Cutlery, no tool is a complete waste. Even the worst tools (except Taylor Cutlery products) have redeeming qualities, and it is worth looking for them- not that I think either of these tools are anywhere near the worst. I very much like both of them, and they have both seen a significant amount of carry and use.

          Def

          EDC-TV
          SAKWiki
          GearFeed
          SAKSelector

          Merit Badges
          Charge Collector Reviewer Outdoor Cook MTO Tool BO Tools Level 3 Time Lord Level 3 One Piece Collector Airgun User Duct Tape Scale Changer EDC Pocket Dump Challenge Def's 50k Challenge Santa
          1 Reply Last reply
          • McStitchy Offline
            McStitchy
            Global Moderators
            Posts: 19,785
            McStitchy Offline
            McStitchy
            Global Moderators
            wrote on last edited by
            #69 Quote Reply

              Thanks Grant for this great review.
              I don't have either of both, and still wouldn't know which one to get without making up my own mind about them :like:

              Merit Badges
              Hacker Hook User Time Lord Level 3 Ignore Photographer Mod User Birth Year SAK Modified SAK Challenge EDC Pocket Dump Challenge OCD Squad LM Wave Challenge Victorinox Spirit Challenge MTo Store User Zip Tie User SAK STACK Challenge 30 Days Calendar 2019 Toothpick User Traditional Folder Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge PST 30 Day Challenge BO Tools Level 2 Calendar 2020 Mr Pinchy Love Bites Soldier 30 Day Challenge 30 Blades 30 Days 30 day EDC Challenge Poker Face Challenge Buck 110 Challenge Gas Station MRE challenge SAK STACK Challenge 60 Days BO Tools Level 3 Chuck Yeager Challenge Soldier On 90 Day Challenge 30 Day Locks Up Challenge Buck 112 Ranger 30 Day Challenge LM OHT Challenge Santa
              1 Reply Last reply
              • ezdog Offline
                ezdog
                Posts: 1,717
                ezdog Offline
                ezdog
                wrote on last edited by
                #70 Quote Reply

                  Nice Review,thanks for taking the time to do it.

                  I have a Skeletool that I can not seem to bond with and I was intrigued by the SOG but when I went to a store to see one I was underwhelmed by what seemed to me an obvious lack of quality or attention to detail and thats as far as I got.

                  I have several SOG' and have always found them among the crude mainstream MT but this ones stamped construction just did not inspire me to get one at all.

                  I appreciate your in depth analysis though and I might have to give another look? :climber:

                  Merit Badges
                  Gerber CD Challenge
                  1 Reply Last reply
                  • Alan K. Offline
                    Alan K.
                    Posts: 8,225
                    Alan K. Offline
                    Alan K.
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #71 Quote Reply

                      I think if you are looking for a tie breaker the Skeletool wins on price because they were a Christmas special at Home Depot in 2016 for under $30.00, and even though they weren't available at that price for the 2017 holidays many of us did buy them when they were on sale, and there's no reason to believe they won't be a Christmas special again in the future.

                      Merit Badges
                      Outdoor Cook Flashlight SOG Power Challenge Hook User The MIDLMAN Challenge Time Lord Level 3 Chainsaw User Paracord Axe User The SUPER Challenge EDC Pocket Dump Challenge Traditional Folder Challenge LM Rebar Challenge Minimal SAK Challenge Mora User Sporkman 111mm SAK Challenge Victorinox Spirit Challenge Duct Tape Gerber MP Challenge OCD Squad MTo Anniversary Challenge Slasher User Fixed Blade Challenge Zip Tie User MTO Rotation Challenge The Huntsman Challenge Keychain Challenge LM Crunch 30 day Challenge Discontinued SAK/MT Challenge Mr Pinchy Love Bites Victorinox SwissTool Challenge SAK STACK Challenge 30 Days The Nessmuk Challenge 30 day EDC Challenge The Batman 30 Day Challenge Poker Face Challenge Buck 110 Challenge Folding Hunter 30 days Challenge Gas Station MRE challenge Old Cross 30 Day Challenge Daredevil challenge SAK-alike Challenge Delemont 30 Day Challenge PST 30 Day Challenge Chuck Yeager Challenge 30 Day Combo Edge Challenge Pen Challenge Loaded Pockets 30 Day Challenge Buck 112 Ranger 30 Day Challenge Jack'O Lantern Badge LM Surge Challenge Level 3 Case XX 30 Day Challenge Gerber CD Challenge 30 DAY OPINEL CHALLENGE Explorer 30 Day Challenge Ignore Utility Knife  30 Day Challenge Buck 30 Day Challenge Wally Badge Chili Award The 30 Day MiniTool Challenge Gun User 20th Anniversary Anything Goes Challenge 30 Day Marlin Spike Challenge 30 Day Barlow Challenge
                      1 Reply Last reply
                      • jaya_man Offline
                        jaya_man
                        Global Moderators
                        Posts: 9,012
                        jaya_man Offline
                        jaya_man
                        Global Moderators
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #72 Quote Reply

                          Awesome wright-up Grant... thanks again...

                          I have a few skeletools and used to edc one before I bought a SOG micro tool clip.. Actually miss the Skeletool too...

                          Your write-up has also opened my eyes to the Reactor... prior to this, the side by side shoot out I’ve seen has always been one sided...

                          Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

                          Merit Badges
                          Scale Changer Flashlight Mod User EDC Pocket Dump Challenge Hacker Ignore Photographer ALOX with Scissors Victorinox Spirit Challenge Paracord 111mm Collector Level 3 Titanium Copper Flashlight Challenge Modified SAK Challenge OCD Squad Camo SAK Stayglow SAK Birth Year SAK MTo Anniversary Challenge Zip Tie User Time Lord Level 3 SAKMC MTo Store User MTO Tool ALOX Colors Level 3 Calendar  2018 BO Tools Level 2 One Piece Collector
                          1 Reply Last reply
                          • ThePeacent Offline
                            ThePeacent
                            Posts: 14,599
                            ThePeacent Offline
                            ThePeacent
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #73 Quote Reply

                              yes, boss, well written and entertaining. :tu:

                              Thanks for such an insightful overview of the tools, I've always put the Skele above the Reactor but this comparison brought up some points I didn't think about, that make it an attractive alternative. :salute:

                              My toys:

                              MTs: Surge (2x), Skeletool CX, Rebar, Blast, Fuse, Micra, Squirt (3x), Wave, Crunch, Mini, Spirit (2x), Pro Scout, MP700 (2x), Diesel, Powerlock, PowerPlier (2x), PocketPowerPlier, Blacktip , ST6 (2x), 5WR, A100

                              SAKs: Bantam, Executive, Ambassador, Minichamp, Classic Alox, Champion, Farmer, Explorer, Swisschamp, Golf Tool, Wenger Champ, EVO 52, Pocket Tool Chest

                              Merit Badges
                              EDC Pocket Dump Challenge Hacker Gerber MP Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge Victorinox Spirit Challenge Flashlight MTO Tool Chainsaw User Hook User The Pioneer X Challenge Buck 110 Challenge Buck User MTO Rotation Challenge Jack'O Lantern Badge
                              1 Reply Last reply
                              • Grant Lamontagne Offline
                                Grant Lamontagne
                                administrators
                                Posts: 67,999
                                Grant Lamontagne Offline
                                Grant Lamontagne
                                administrators
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #74 Quote Reply

                                  @Alan K. said:
                                  I think if you are looking for a tie breaker the Skeletool wins on price because they were a Christmas special at Home Depot in 2016 for under $30.00, and even though they weren't available at that price for the 2017 holidays many of us did buy them when they were on sale, and there's no reason to believe they won't be a Christmas special again in the future.

                                  The Skeletool already won a point based on price.

                                  With pricing I always go with MSRP because it is the only fair way to do it- after all, I got this Reactor free from SOG for review purposes, and I bought that Skeletool. By that logic, the Reactor should have won the price point because it cost me less, even though that isn't a deal that just anyone can go out and get any time. Also, as a registered SOG dealer but not a Leatherman dealer, I can but SOG products at wholesale (cheaper) than I can buy Leatherman products (retail), so again Leatherman would have lost their point here.

                                  I will always hold to MSRP for these things because there are always deals to be had, but MSRP is a benchmark that all brands adhere to, and it's only fair to have them all compete on the same level.

                                  Def

                                  EDC-TV
                                  SAKWiki
                                  GearFeed
                                  SAKSelector

                                  Merit Badges
                                  Charge Collector Reviewer Outdoor Cook MTO Tool BO Tools Level 3 Time Lord Level 3 One Piece Collector Airgun User Duct Tape Scale Changer EDC Pocket Dump Challenge Def's 50k Challenge Santa
                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  • mcb Offline
                                    mcb
                                    Posts: 42
                                    mcb Offline
                                    mcb
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #75 Quote Reply

                                      Great review! :like: I though the final part was probably the best. :tu: As someone that has owned and carried both I have to say that the Skeletool is the winner for me personally. The quality of the build is evident the first time you use the tool hard. The Leatherman is just stiffer, tighter and more refined. I think a lot of SOG tools would benefit from making the sheet-metal they use in the handle from steel just a few thousands of an inch thicker. Yes that it not simple change but it would make a huge difference to how stiff the tool feel in the hand under heavy use.

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      • Old Boy Offline
                                        Old Boy
                                        Posts: 1,107
                                        Old Boy Offline
                                        Old Boy
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #76 Quote Reply

                                          Special request for a tie breaker. How about which tool has Joie de vivre? ;)

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          • Grant Lamontagne Offline
                                            Grant Lamontagne
                                            administrators
                                            Posts: 67,999
                                            Grant Lamontagne Offline
                                            Grant Lamontagne
                                            administrators
                                            wrote on last edited by
                                            #77 Quote Reply

                                              @OldBoy2016 said:
                                              Special request for a tie breaker. How about which tool has Joie de vivre? ;)

                                              The reactor because the assisted opening blade is fun to play with. :P

                                              Def

                                              EDC-TV
                                              SAKWiki
                                              GearFeed
                                              SAKSelector

                                              Merit Badges
                                              Charge Collector Reviewer Outdoor Cook MTO Tool BO Tools Level 3 Time Lord Level 3 One Piece Collector Airgun User Duct Tape Scale Changer EDC Pocket Dump Challenge Def's 50k Challenge Santa
                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                              • Old Boy Offline
                                                Old Boy
                                                Posts: 1,107
                                                Old Boy Offline
                                                Old Boy
                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                #78 Quote Reply

                                                  Darn it! I was hoping you’d say Skeletool coz it’s sexy.

                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                  • Poncho65 Offline
                                                    Poncho65
                                                    Global Moderators
                                                    Posts: 87,638
                                                    Poncho65 Offline
                                                    Poncho65
                                                    Global Moderators
                                                    wrote on last edited by
                                                    #79 Quote Reply

                                                      Great write up and glad both were given a fair chance :like: I have a Skeley and have looked at the Reactor several times but never have gotten one :D If the QC may be better in the near future I may very well get one then though :tu:

                                                      Merit Badges
                                                      BO Tools Level 2 Japanese PST Reviewer Photographer Axe User Fire Making Hacker Multitool Encyclopedia User OCD Squad Time Lord Level 1 Mod User Duct Tape Discontinued SAK/MT Challenge The SUPER Challenge EDC Pocket Dump Challenge Def's 50k Challenge LM Rebar Challenge Traditional Folder Challenge Gerber MP Challenge Modified SAK Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge Victorinox SwissTool Challenge LM Surge Challenge Level 2 Victorinox Spirit Challenge MTO Rotation Challenge LM Wave Challenge Calendar   2017 Calendar  2018 Calendar 2019 LM Surge Challenge Level 3 Keychain Challenge LM Crunch 15 day Challenge LM OHT Challenge PST 30 Day Challenge Calendar 2020 14th Anniversary Anything Goes Challenge Skeletool 30 Day Challenge The Batman 30 Day Challenge Poker Face Challenge Daredevil challenge The 30 Day MiniTool Challenge 30 Day Locks Up Challenge One Piece Collector 30 Day Rhymes with Orange Challenge Bond 30 Day Challenge Wally Badge 30 Day Ratchet Challenge
                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                      • AimlessWanderer Offline
                                                        AimlessWanderer
                                                        Posts: 17,518
                                                        AimlessWanderer Offline
                                                        AimlessWanderer
                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                        #80 Quote Reply

                                                          Nice work, Grant. :tu:

                                                          I think that was a fair and balanced appraisal, and not just balanced in the end result. I wouldn't agree with every point, but then nobody would. We all value things slightly differently, based on our own needs and preferences. That said, I do not have any significant arguements with any of the findings herein.

                                                          From my own perspective, I have commented in the past about the ergonomics of the Skeletool, the fact that SOG's compound leverage is great for amplifying gripping force on smaller items, but actually reduces gripping force on larger items due to making the grip ergonomically inefficient, and SOG's reputation for inferior quality over the last few years.

                                                          However, I think my dislike of both these tools is more fundamental to the tool format. Kampfer has rightly said in the past, that the Skele is unlike other "pliers based" tools, and is more of a "knife with pliers" than "pliers with a knife". The Reactor has done a good job of capturing that same essence of form. However, it's not a knife form that I have any liking or need for. I appreciate that some people like the locking knife format, but is I can't do a job with a slippie, I need a fixed blade, not one that is pretending to be. I certainly have no interest whatsoever in any kind of assisted blade, or any other "tacticool" elemental.

                                                          I am simply the wrong person for these tools.

                                                          If I DID have a genuine requirement for a one hand opening locking blade, that happened to have pliers and screwdrivers, which would I go for? Well I would got for one which I felt gave me the best ergonomics, and the one that I trusted the most. For me, that would be the Buck X-Tract, or X-Tract Fin. I recognise that is a discontinued model, but I happen to have one, and would rather reach for that than either of the two reviewed here.

                                                          I find the "insight" into SOG's sudden interest in quality improvements, to be disappointingly overdue. For four (or is it five) years now, they have been cementing their position as a company who cares very little about quality. Interested in design concepts, maybe, and in profit margins, but not in refining the concepts, ensuring that concepts are properly realised in the manufacturing stages, making sure that the products are indeed of useable tool quality, or giving a crap about their reputation in the marketplace.

                                                          If SOG are listening, and I hope they are, they need to understand and be prepared to accept that even if every single tool they sold from today onwards, was of the quality that they should have been for the last few years, this is going to be a slow recovery of customer trust. They have pumped many disappointing tools out for several years, and that kind of reputation damage doesn't get swept under the carpet quickly. They now need to consistently put TOOLS on the market, instead of novelty "dad gifts". Not just one or two, but the whole line, and make sure each and every current product, and every subsequent new release, can be carried and USED in real life applications with full confidence. Even then, it may take five years of high quality tools, to start undoing the damage from five years of defects, misinformation, and sloppily built overpriced gadgets. There's no quick fix, fellers - but you've only yourselves to blame. Good luck in your recovery.

                                                          The cantankerous but occasionally useful member, formally known as 50ft-trad

                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                          • Nix Offline
                                                            Nix
                                                            Posts: 24,263
                                                            Nix Offline
                                                            Nix
                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                            #81 Quote Reply

                                                              Good addition to the argument, Trad.

                                                              I'm a fan of a locking knife because it is safer than a slip joint. Now, I love me a traditional slip joint, but I always feel safer using a locking knife. Or, at least, a knife that locks securely.

                                                              These comments are coming from a guy who prefers to carry a fixed blade knife (and frequently does so). No one will ever convince me that a folder is a good substitute for a fixie, but in modern societies they aren't as well accepted as they should be (according to me :D). So we are left with tiny knives that fold. And here a locking knife blade is a good idea for safety and security.

                                                              I agree with your assessment that the Skeletool is a knife with pliers as opposed to a pair of pliers with a knife. This is true from my perspective. But, sometimes I want a knife (the tool I use the most) and think it might be nice to have some pliers along for the ride. In this respect, the Skele and Reactor do fill a specific role or, perhaps better, a specific set of anticipated needs.

                                                              In the end, I don't carry my Skele as often as I have my Charge or, now, REBAR. But I like having it as an option. In this respect I think Leatherman and SOG should continue to evaluate, improve, and produce these tools. Options is good. :tu:

                                                              Merit Badges
                                                              Hook User ALOX with Scissors ALOX Colors Level 3 The Pioneer X Challenge Camo SAK Birth Year SAK Minimal SAK Challenge Sporkman Paracord LM Rebar Challenge MTO Tool MTo Store User Zip Tie User Victorinox Spirit Challenge EDC Pocket Dump Challenge Santa 111mm SAK Challenge Fire Making OCD Squad Scale Changer Buck 110 Challenge Buck User Mod User 111mm Collector Level 1 SAKMC Fishing SOG Power Challenge Axe User Chuck Yeager Challenge Outdoor Cook LM Wave Challenge The Huntsman Challenge Titanium Mora User SAK STACK Challenge 30 Days Fixed Blade Challenge Toothpick User The SUPER Challenge Hacker Traditional Folder Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge 30 Day Axe Challenge PST 30 Day Challenge Chili Award Buck 112 Ranger 30 Day Challenge Fieldmaster 30 Day Challenge Victorinox SwissTool Challenge Soldier 30 Day Challenge 30 Blades 30 Days Spyderco 30 Day Challenge The Nessmuk Challenge Skeletool 30 Day Challenge 30 day EDC Challenge Poker Face Challenge Farmer X Challenge Gas Station MRE challenge 30 day challenge - 58, 65 and 74mm SAKs GEC Challenge SAK STACK Challenge 60 Days Delemont 30 Day Challenge Soldier On 90 Day Challenge Pen Challenge
                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                              • ezdog Offline
                                                                ezdog
                                                                Posts: 1,717
                                                                ezdog Offline
                                                                ezdog
                                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                                #82 Quote Reply

                                                                  All good points as were the ones before yours but the issue that I have with both tools here is that they not only seem like 1/2 tool sets but lesser quality for it as well?
                                                                  They seem to think that there is a need to cut corners for price and/or weight while making the tool a crippled version of the real deal too.

                                                                  Take Vic though where pretty much any SAK that you get from the smallest to the biggest is still pretty much the same quality and design just scaled for different needs but always a good value for the quality regardless!

                                                                  I would jump all over a small Spirit X Mini that was pint sized and just a shrunken Spirit in body & Spirit but the idea of throwing good money for the Skeletool for instance leads me to consider the Rebar or even Sidekick/Wingman for the same price where each is a pretty serious Heavy Duty tool in their own right.

                                                                  @Nix said:
                                                                  Good addition to the argument, Trad.

                                                                  I'm a fan of a locking knife because it is safer than a slip joint. Now, I love me a traditional slip joint, but I always feel safer using a locking knife. Or, at least, a knife that locks securely.

                                                                  These comments are coming from a guy who prefers to carry a fixed blade knife (and frequently does so). No one will ever convince me that a folder is a good substitute for a fixie, but in modern societies they aren't as well accepted as they should be (according to me :D). So we are left with tiny knives that fold. And here a locking knife blade is a good idea for safety and security.

                                                                  I agree with your assessment that the Skeletool is a knife with pliers as opposed to a pair of pliers with a knife. This is true from my perspective. But, sometimes I want a knife (the tool I use the most) and think it might be nice to have some pliers along for the ride. In this respect, the Skele and Reactor do fill a specific role or, perhaps better, a specific set of anticipated needs.

                                                                  In the end, I don't carry my Skele as often as I have my Charge or, now, REBAR. But I like having it as an option. In this respect I think Leatherman and SOG should continue to evaluate, improve, and produce these tools. Options is good. :tu:

                                                                  Merit Badges
                                                                  Gerber CD Challenge
                                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                                  • AimlessWanderer Offline
                                                                    AimlessWanderer
                                                                    Posts: 17,518
                                                                    AimlessWanderer Offline
                                                                    AimlessWanderer
                                                                    wrote on last edited by
                                                                    #83 Quote Reply

                                                                      @Nix said:
                                                                      I'm a fan of a locking knife because it is safer than a slip joint. Now, I love me a traditional slip joint, but I always feel safer using a locking knife. Or, at least, a knife that locks securely.

                                                                      I find slipjoints to be safer. I have had far more nicks and cuts from locking blades than non-locking blades - particularly back locks, which I now refuse to use, but also from many liner locks too. I do appreciate that I am deep in minority territory on that one...

                                                                      @Nix said:
                                                                      I agree with your assessment that the Skeletool is a knife with pliers as opposed to a pair of pliers with a knife. This is true from my perspective. But, sometimes I want a knife (the tool I use the most) and think it might be nice to have some pliers along for the ride. In this respect, the Skele and Reactor do fill a specific role or, perhaps better, a specific set of anticipated needs.

                                                                      I much prefer to have a stand alone pocket knife than the knife on any pliers tool. I consider my pliers tool to be my pocket "everything else other than a knife", and would rather they made it knifeless, and put something else useful in it's place. I'm still in the minority on this one too, but a larger minority this time.

                                                                      @Nix said:
                                                                      Options is good. :tu:

                                                                      On this, I agree 100% :tu: :salute:

                                                                      The cantankerous but occasionally useful member, formally known as 50ft-trad

                                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                                      • Nix Offline
                                                                        Nix
                                                                        Posts: 24,263
                                                                        Nix Offline
                                                                        Nix
                                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                                        #84 Quote Reply

                                                                          I had a couple of cuts after my Spyderco Endura's lock failed (two or three times). I was seriously annoyed and wrote to Spyderco: "your back-lock fails!". This was in 1997. They wrote back and told me I was wrong. What the smurf?!? I had the Band-Aid bill to prove it!

                                                                          A few years later they came out with the "Boye Detent" and I felt vindicated. Since then, though, I've never had a lock fail. And I ain't kind to my knives.

                                                                          So, I'm not dismissing your concerns, but I don't have the same experience that you do. I'm quite confident in most (99%) of my locking knives and far, far more confident in my locking knives than I am in my slippies. Of course, my concern about the safety of my slip joints may make me more cautious when using them, and that might be a safety advantage. :tu:

                                                                          (Hey, nice arguing with you, Trad!)

                                                                          Merit Badges
                                                                          Hook User ALOX with Scissors ALOX Colors Level 3 The Pioneer X Challenge Camo SAK Birth Year SAK Minimal SAK Challenge Sporkman Paracord LM Rebar Challenge MTO Tool MTo Store User Zip Tie User Victorinox Spirit Challenge EDC Pocket Dump Challenge Santa 111mm SAK Challenge Fire Making OCD Squad Scale Changer Buck 110 Challenge Buck User Mod User 111mm Collector Level 1 SAKMC Fishing SOG Power Challenge Axe User Chuck Yeager Challenge Outdoor Cook LM Wave Challenge The Huntsman Challenge Titanium Mora User SAK STACK Challenge 30 Days Fixed Blade Challenge Toothpick User The SUPER Challenge Hacker Traditional Folder Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge 30 Day Axe Challenge PST 30 Day Challenge Chili Award Buck 112 Ranger 30 Day Challenge Fieldmaster 30 Day Challenge Victorinox SwissTool Challenge Soldier 30 Day Challenge 30 Blades 30 Days Spyderco 30 Day Challenge The Nessmuk Challenge Skeletool 30 Day Challenge 30 day EDC Challenge Poker Face Challenge Farmer X Challenge Gas Station MRE challenge 30 day challenge - 58, 65 and 74mm SAKs GEC Challenge SAK STACK Challenge 60 Days Delemont 30 Day Challenge Soldier On 90 Day Challenge Pen Challenge
                                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                                          • AimlessWanderer Offline
                                                                            AimlessWanderer
                                                                            Posts: 17,518
                                                                            AimlessWanderer Offline
                                                                            AimlessWanderer
                                                                            wrote on last edited by AimlessWanderer
                                                                            #85 Quote Reply

                                                                              @Nix said:
                                                                              I had a couple of cuts after my Spyderco Endura's lock failed (two or three times). I was seriously annoyed and wrote to Spyderco: "your back-lock fails!". This was in 1997. They wrote back and told me I was wrong. What the smurf?!? I had the Band-Aid bill to prove it!

                                                                              A few years later they came out with the "Boye Detent" and I felt vindicated. Since then, though, I've never had a lock fail. And I ain't kind to my knives.

                                                                              So, I'm not dismissing your concerns, but I don't have the same experience that you do. I'm quite confident in most (99%) of my locking knives and far, far more confident in my locking knives than I am in my slippies. Of course, my concern about the safety of my slip joints may make me more cautious when using them, and that might be a safety advantage. :tu:

                                                                              (Hey, nice arguing with you, Trad!)

                                                                              Oh, it's not the lock failing that's drawn blood here. It's the having to put your fingers in the path of the blade to unlock it.

                                                                              I've never had a lock fail, because I never use it so that the lock is needed - or in other words, I use it like a slipjoint. If I ever do anything that warrants a lock, it's time for a different tool. If there are no other tools, i'll modify the usage so the lock isn't loaded (such as a pinch hold on the blade itself). Cutting through something where the blade might jam? Raise the handle first, so you're rolling the knife out.

                                                                              Every lock knife cut that I've had has been from closing the blade, either one handed, or two handed while my attention has been elsewhere. One hand closing is way more important to me than one hand opening (though it's nice to have both), and I can safely one handed close a slippy with less chance of a cut than I can a blade that locks but doesn't need to :D

                                                                              I've also had near misses purely due to unfamiliarity. I was using a 111mm Vic once, and totally forgot the blade locked. I went to close it as if it was a slippy, and just pushed the blade out of my hand, and it landed point down. Luckily, I managed to get my foot out of the way in time.

                                                                              When I tell people that I consider slippies to be safer than locking blades, they tend to look at me as if my head buttons up the back. That level of confusion that they have in that moment, is the exact same confusion that I have when someone says a locking blade is safer. Seriously! I genuinely do not understand how anyone is "safely" using a folding knife, in such a way that the lock is needed? That means the blade is under force the wrong way. :ahhh Even when making piercing cuts, I always make sure the forces are going the right way, pushing the blade open. Unless I'm missing something, that means no lock needed.

                                                                              :shrug:

                                                                              No arguing. Just a friendly exchange of different perspectives :cheers:

                                                                              The cantankerous but occasionally useful member, formally known as 50ft-trad

                                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                                              • Nix Offline
                                                                                Nix
                                                                                Posts: 24,263
                                                                                Nix Offline
                                                                                Nix
                                                                                wrote on last edited by Nix
                                                                                #86 Quote Reply

                                                                                  No arguing. Just a friendly exchange of different perspectives.

                                                                                  Smurf it all, Trad! Let's fight!

                                                                                  Here is how I recall my Endura failing and cutting me (this may all be a lie, but I think it's true.): I was trying to cut through a thick branch. I made a Herculean cut with exuberance. A real Conan-the-Barbarian kind of cut. As the blade passed through the branch, all the force of the cut was dissipated. The blade then had a large amount of momentum. That momentum was translated into angular velocity focused around the pivot point. With my knuckle actuating the lock--at least in part--the blade was released to rotate around the pivot point and whack my fingers. Whack 'em with the sharp bit. FAIL.

                                                                                  And this is the safety concern. A force applied to a blade correctly pushes the blade into the 'open' position. But once that force doesn't have an "opposite and equal" force applied by the medium being cut, funny things happen. Inertia and the forces of deceleration come into play. And then close that razor sharp edge on yer fingers. For that reason, a lock offers--in my over-confident opinion--a margin of safety against the inertial forces at play when an open blade is being rapidly decelerated. Baseball players are known to break baseball bats by rapidly checking their swings to avoid a strike. I'm not claiming to have the wrists of an MLB batter, but the principle is the same. A lock doesn't prevent disaster, but it's better than no safety mechanism at all. :whistle:

                                                                                  Merit Badges
                                                                                  Hook User ALOX with Scissors ALOX Colors Level 3 The Pioneer X Challenge Camo SAK Birth Year SAK Minimal SAK Challenge Sporkman Paracord LM Rebar Challenge MTO Tool MTo Store User Zip Tie User Victorinox Spirit Challenge EDC Pocket Dump Challenge Santa 111mm SAK Challenge Fire Making OCD Squad Scale Changer Buck 110 Challenge Buck User Mod User 111mm Collector Level 1 SAKMC Fishing SOG Power Challenge Axe User Chuck Yeager Challenge Outdoor Cook LM Wave Challenge The Huntsman Challenge Titanium Mora User SAK STACK Challenge 30 Days Fixed Blade Challenge Toothpick User The SUPER Challenge Hacker Traditional Folder Challenge MTo Anniversary Challenge 30 Day Axe Challenge PST 30 Day Challenge Chili Award Buck 112 Ranger 30 Day Challenge Fieldmaster 30 Day Challenge Victorinox SwissTool Challenge Soldier 30 Day Challenge 30 Blades 30 Days Spyderco 30 Day Challenge The Nessmuk Challenge Skeletool 30 Day Challenge 30 day EDC Challenge Poker Face Challenge Farmer X Challenge Gas Station MRE challenge 30 day challenge - 58, 65 and 74mm SAKs GEC Challenge SAK STACK Challenge 60 Days Delemont 30 Day Challenge Soldier On 90 Day Challenge Pen Challenge
                                                                                  1 Reply Last reply

                                                                                  Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                                                                  Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                                                                  With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                                                                  Register Login

                                                                                  • 1
                                                                                  • 2
                                                                                  • 3
                                                                                  • 4
                                                                                  • 5
                                                                                  1. Home
                                                                                  2. Tool Talk
                                                                                  3. General Tool Discussion
                                                                                  4. Shootout- Leatherman Skeletool vs SOG Reactor
                                                                                  Reply
                                                                                  • Reply as topic
                                                                                  Log in to reply
                                                                                  COMMUNITY LINKS
                                                                                  EDC-TV SAKWiki GearFeed SAKSelector
                                                                                  Operational Funds

                                                                                  Help us keep the Unworkable working!

                                                                                  Make A Donation
                                                                                  November Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  Due Date: Nov 30
                                                                                  Total Receipts: $0.00
                                                                                  Below Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  0% funded
                                                                                  • Login

                                                                                  • Don't have an account? Register

                                                                                  • Login or register to search.
                                                                                  • First post
                                                                                    Last post
                                                                                  0