MT scissors comparison
-
Preceded by Lynn LeFey's (and others) scissors tests and inspired by ReamerPunch's can opener comparison, I have decided to perform
my own comparison of multi tool scissors. I have tried to use a variety of materials to one would think a multi tool owner might need
to cut or may highlight multi tool scissors' strengths and weaknesses, all the while taking note of materials that others have deemed
to be test worthy.The scoring is subjective to some degree and is not very reliable for ranking scissors of similiar quality. Your scoring may vary from mine.
Also, there is probably some variability in the quality of the construction for the different brands and models of multi tools.
I am using only one sample per model, and my sample may be better or worse than the typical model. Finally, scissors with an overall
lower score may work well for your purposes.I do not have a complete list of the scissors I am testing. However, here is the list of scissors I have tested so far:
Fiskars 5" scissors (my control)
Victorinox Super Tinker
Leatherman Micra
NexTool Mini Flagship
Gerber Armbar Drive
SOG Snippet
Leatherman Squirt S4
Leatherman Juice CS3
SOG Baton Q1
Leatherman PST II
Wenger EVO Grip 14
Craftsman 10 in 1
Victorinox Classic SD
AceCamp 11 in 1I hope that this information is of use to somebody, but I will not be too disappointed if it isn't. I am having fun trying out different tools.
Though, if my wife asks, tell her that my tests are very important
-
Fiskars 5" scissors

The Fiskars 5" scissors are being used as the control in the scissors testing. They should outperform most, if not all, MT scissors.
That being said, they are light duty, so they may experience some difficulty in cutting tougher materials.Thread - 3
Mason cord - 3
Jute - 3
550 Paracord - 3
4 lb monofilament fishing line - 3
0.065" trimmer string - 3
10 lb braided fishing line - 3
Denim - 3
Cloth - 3
Tissue - 3
Felt - 3
Cardboard - 3
Plastic bag - 3
Padded envelope - 3
Webbing - 3
Zip tie - 3
Nylon rope - 2.5
Stranded copper wire - 3
18 awg copper wire - 3
Plastic container - 3
Rubber ball - 3
Leather belt - 1
Cutting out simple pattern on paper - 3
Ergonomics - 3Total - 69.5/72
*Scoring:
Effectively cuts material with minimal effort = 3
Requires an extra snip or some extra effort = 2.5
Will cut material, but requires holding material taunt or finding sweet spot on scissors = 2
Scissors tends to gnaw through material rather than cut cleanly - 1.5
Will cut material roughly and with great effort - 1
May be able to cut material, but not worth the effort - 0.5
Can not cut material - 0
*
The only item that presented a problem was the leather belt. I could not generate enough force to easily cut through the leather.
I had to focus on nibbling at the leather in order to make any process with the cut. Otherwise, the scissors performed as advertised. -
Super Tinker (91mm SAK)

Thread - 3
Mason cord - 3
Jute - 3
550 Paracord - 2.5
4 lb monofilament fishing line - 3
0.065" trimmer string - 3
10 lb braided fishing line - 2.5
Denim - 3
Cloth - 3
Tissue - 3
Felt - 3
Cardboard - 3
Plastic bag - 3
Padded envelope - 3
Webbing - 3
Zip tie - 3
Nylon rope - 2
Stranded copper wire - 3
18 awg copper wire - 2.5
Plastic container - 3
Rubber ball - 3
Leather belt - 2
Cutting out simple pattern on paper - 3
Ergonomics - 3Total - 68.5/72
Scoring:
Effectively cuts material with minimal effort = 3
Requires an extra snip or some extra effort = 2.5
Will cut material, but requires holding material taunt or finding sweet spot on scissors = 2
Scissors tends to gnaw through material rather than cut cleanly - 1.5
Will cut material roughly and with great effort - 1
May be able to cut material, but not worth the effort - 0.5
Can not cut material - 0Unsurprisingly to those in the know, the scissors on the Super Tinker (the representative 91 mm SAK for this test) are quite good.
However, there was some tendency for the material to be pushed away from the pivot, which affected its ability to cut the paracord and the nylon rope cleanly. Also, it was difficult to generate enough force to cut the leather belt. Finally, when cutting the denim I found that the spring did not effectively reopen the scissors after each cut. -
Leatherman Micra

Thread - 3
Mason cord - 3
Jute - 2
550 Paracord - 1.5
4 lb fishing line - 3
0.065" trimmer string - 2
10 lb braided fishing line - 2
Denim - 2
Cloth - 2
Tissue - 2
Felt - 2.5
Cardboard - 2
Plastic bag - 3
Padded envelope - 2.5
Webbing - 1.5
Zip tie - 3
Nylon rope - 1
Stranded copper wire - 3
18 awg copper wire - 3
Plastic container - 3
Rubber ball - 2
Leather belt - 2
Cutting out simple pattern on paper - 3
Ergonomics - 2.5Total - 56.5/72
Scoring:
Effectively cuts material with minimal effort = 3
Requires an extra snip or some extra effort = 2.5
Will cut material, but requires holding material taunt or finding sweet spot on scissors = 2
Scissors tends to gnaw through material rather than cut cleanly - 1.5
Will cut material roughly and with great effort - 1
May be able to cut material, but not worth the effort - 0.5
Can not cut material - 0Material had some tendency to fold up between the scissors instead of being cut. They did cut better near the pivot than near the tips.
I found the handles to be a bit pinchy and edgy, but they did allow me to generate some cutting power. -
NexTool Mini Flagship

Thread - 3
Mason cord - 3
Jute - 3
550 Paracord - 3
4 lb fishing line - 3
0.065" trimmer string - 3
10 lb braided fishing line - 2
Denim - 3
Cloth - 3
Tissue - 3
Felt - 3
Cardboard - 3
Plastic bag - 3
Padded envelope - 3
Webbing - 2
Zip tie - 3
Nylon rope - 2.5
Stranded copper wire - 3
18 awg copper wire - 3
Plastic container - 3
Rubber ball - 3
Leather belt - 3
Cutting out simple pattern on paper - 3
Ergonomics - 1.5Total - 68/72
Scoring:
Effectively cuts material with minimal effort = 3
Requires an extra snip or some extra effort = 2.5
Will cut material, but requires holding material taunt or finding sweet spot on scissors = 2
Scissors tends to gnaw through material rather than cut cleanly - 1.5
Will cut material roughly and with great effort - 1
May be able to cut material, but not worth the effort - 0.5
Can not cut material - 0In general, the NexTool Mini Flagship has good, almost great scissors, able to cut a variety of materials well.
Only the webbing and the braided fishing line gave it some trouble. However, it is lacking ergonomically. Though I could generate
plenty of power, the handles are very edgy, and the end of the handle that is used to deploy the scissors also dug into my palm.
Not to mention that the tip of the scissors cut my thumb one time while deploying them. Finally, more than once the keyring attached
to the tool got in the way of closing the handles while using the scissors.Note:
ReamerPunch owns a Mini Flagship, and the scissor spring after very little usage. That does not mean you would have the same (bad) luck,
but confidence in its durability should be somewhat diminished. -
More to come
-

Spoiler:
SURGE!!!
-
@Adam5 said:
NexTool Mini Flagship
Note:
ReamerPunch owns a Mini Flagship, and the scissor spring after very little usage. That does not mean you would have the same (bad) luck,
but confidence in its durability should be somewhat diminished.ReamerPunch is not alone, I had the same experience and I recently noticed that Nextool sells the scissor handle as a spare part. Whether this inspires confidence (because it can be fixed if it breaks) or distrust (because it implies that this failure is a common occurrence) is anyone's choice.
-
Thank you for this. Its always interesting to see such tests.
-
Here are some pictures of the materials being used in the test/comparison:

Thread, Mason Cord, Jute, 550 Paracord, 4lb monofilament fishing line, 0.065" trimmer string, 10lb braided fishing line
Denim, Cloth, Tissue, Felt, Plastic Bag, Padded Envelope, Cardboard
Webbing, Zip Tie, 18 awg Copper Wire, Stranded Copper Wire, Nylon Rope, Plastic Container, Rubber Ball, Leather Belt
Pattern -
Gerber Armbar Drive

Thread - 3
Mason cord - 3
Jute - 3
550 Paracord - 1.5
4 lb monofilament fishing line - 3
0.065" trimmer string - 3
10 lb braided fishing line - 3
Denim - 1.5
Cloth - 2
Tissue - 2
Felt - 2
Cardboard - 0
Plastic bag - 3
Padded envelope - 3
Webbing - 1.5
Zip tie - 2.5
Nylon rope - 1.5
Stranded copper wire - 2
18 awg copper wire - 3
Plastic container - 0
Rubber ball - 1.5
Leather belt - 0
Cutting out simple pattern on paper - 2
Ergonomics - 2.5Total - 49.5/72
Scoring:
Effectively cuts material with minimal effort = 3
Requires an extra snip or some extra effort = 2.5
Will cut material, but requires holding material taunt or finding sweet spot on scissors = 2
Scissors tends to gnaw through material rather than cut cleanly - 1.5
Will cut material roughly and with great effort - 1
May be able to cut material, but not worth the effort - 0.5
Can not cut material - 0
Disappointing performance. There is not enough leverage to cut tougher materials well. The bevel of the scissor edges seem to be a bit more obtuse than other scissors, which does not help. But the edges are not dull, as witnessed by its ability to cut the braided fishing line. Also, the construction of the scissors does not extend the thumb pad beyond or above the pivot. When pressing the thumb pad down fully to complete a cut, my thumb was obstructed a bit by the pivot. -
Craftsman 10 in 1

Thread - 2
Mason cord - 2
Jute - 2
550 Paracord - 2
4 lb monofilament fishing line - 2
0.065" trimmer string - 3
10 lb braided fishing line - 1.5
Denim - 2.5
Cloth - 2.5
Tissue - 2
Felt - 0
Cardboard - 3
Plastic bag - 2
Padded envelope - 2.5
Webbing - 2.5
Zip tie - 3
Nylon rope - 2.5
Stranded copper wire - 3
18 awg copper wire - 3
Plastic container - 3
Rubber ball - 3
Leather belt - 2.5
Cutting out simple pattern on paper - 3
Ergonomics - 3Total - 57.5/72
Scoring:
Effectively cuts material with minimal effort = 3
Requires an extra snip or some extra effort = 2.5
Will cut material, but requires holding material taunt or finding sweet spot on scissors = 2
Scissors tends to gnaw through material rather than cut cleanly - 1.5
Will cut material roughly and with great effort - 1
May be able to cut material, but not worth the effort - 0.5
Can not cut material - 0I had to cut near the tips for finer materials (last 1/4th of scissors). That is the only section where the edges meet. Otherwise, they perform well. Nice handles that, while maybe a bit bulky for keychain tool, felt good in my hand and allowed me to generate power.
-
Leatherman S4

Thread - 3
Mason cord - 3
Jute - 2.5
550 Paracord - 2
4 lb monofilament fishing line - 3
0.065" trimmer string - 3
10 lb braided fishing line - 3
Denim - 3
Cloth - 3
Tissue - 3
Felt - 3
Cardboard - 3
Plastic bag - 3
Padded envelope - 3
Webbing - 3
Zip tie - 3
Nylon rope - 2
Stranded copper wire - 3
18 awg copper wire - 3
Plastic container - 3
Rubber ball - 3
Leather belt - 2.5
Cutting out simple pattern on paper - 3
Ergonomics - 3Total - 69/72
Scoring:
Effectively cuts material with minimal effort = 3
Requires an extra snip or some extra effort = 2.5
Will cut material, but requires holding material taunt or finding sweet spot on scissors = 2
Scissors tends to gnaw through material rather than cut cleanly - 1.5
Will cut material roughly and with great effort - 1
May be able to cut material, but not worth the effort - 0.5
Can not cut material - 0Cuts better towards the tips than the pivot. It does cut very well if you stay in the sweet spot.
-
SOG Snippet

Thread - 3
Mason cord - 3
Jute - 3
550 Paracord - 2
4 lb monofilament fishing line - 3
0.065" trimmer string - 3
10 lb braided fishing line - 3
Denim - 3
Cloth - 3
Tissue - 3
Felt - 3
Cardboard - 3
Plastic bag - 3
Padded envelope - 3
Webbing - 2.5
Zip tie - 3
Nylon rope - 2.5
Stranded copper wire - 3
18 awg copper wire - 3
Plastic container - 3
Rubber ball - 3
Leather belt - 0
Cutting out simple pattern on paper - 3
Ergonomics - 1Total - 65/72
Scoring:
Effectively cuts material with minimal effort = 3
Requires an extra snip or some extra effort = 2.5
Will cut material, but requires holding material taunt or finding sweet spot on scissors = 2
Scissors tends to gnaw through material rather than cut cleanly - 1.5
Will cut material roughly and with great effort - 1
May be able to cut material, but not worth the effort - 0.5
Can not cut material - 0The Snippet does not have a spring for opening the scissors. Instead, it has a couple of outer handles that let the tool operate in the manner typical scissors do. Overall, the Snippet cuts well. But it is by far the least comfortable of all the scissors MTs that I have used.
-
Great thread Adam.

Surprised to see a notable difference between your Micra and Squirt. I know they're not actually the same scissor head but I didn't think there was a practical difference. Could age and wear be a factor?
-
@Gareth said:
Great thread Adam.
Surprised to see a notable difference between your Micra and Squirt. I know they're not actually the same scissor head but I didn't think there was a practical difference. Could age and wear be a factor?
Thanks Gareth :D
Well, the Micra is new and the S4 is like new, so the difference isn't due to age and wear.
Some of the difference can probably be attributed to variances in manufactoring. If several Micras were tested, some of them may perform better then the one I have.
-
Any chance of you (or anyone) graphing the results one day?
-

I was thinking of the individual scores too. But that would be a lot of work.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
