MT scissors comparison
-
Here are some pictures of the materials being used in the test/comparison:

Thread, Mason Cord, Jute, 550 Paracord, 4lb monofilament fishing line, 0.065" trimmer string, 10lb braided fishing line
Denim, Cloth, Tissue, Felt, Plastic Bag, Padded Envelope, Cardboard
Webbing, Zip Tie, 18 awg Copper Wire, Stranded Copper Wire, Nylon Rope, Plastic Container, Rubber Ball, Leather Belt
Pattern -
Gerber Armbar Drive

Thread - 3
Mason cord - 3
Jute - 3
550 Paracord - 1.5
4 lb monofilament fishing line - 3
0.065" trimmer string - 3
10 lb braided fishing line - 3
Denim - 1.5
Cloth - 2
Tissue - 2
Felt - 2
Cardboard - 0
Plastic bag - 3
Padded envelope - 3
Webbing - 1.5
Zip tie - 2.5
Nylon rope - 1.5
Stranded copper wire - 2
18 awg copper wire - 3
Plastic container - 0
Rubber ball - 1.5
Leather belt - 0
Cutting out simple pattern on paper - 2
Ergonomics - 2.5Total - 49.5/72
Scoring:
Effectively cuts material with minimal effort = 3
Requires an extra snip or some extra effort = 2.5
Will cut material, but requires holding material taunt or finding sweet spot on scissors = 2
Scissors tends to gnaw through material rather than cut cleanly - 1.5
Will cut material roughly and with great effort - 1
May be able to cut material, but not worth the effort - 0.5
Can not cut material - 0
Disappointing performance. There is not enough leverage to cut tougher materials well. The bevel of the scissor edges seem to be a bit more obtuse than other scissors, which does not help. But the edges are not dull, as witnessed by its ability to cut the braided fishing line. Also, the construction of the scissors does not extend the thumb pad beyond or above the pivot. When pressing the thumb pad down fully to complete a cut, my thumb was obstructed a bit by the pivot. -
Craftsman 10 in 1

Thread - 2
Mason cord - 2
Jute - 2
550 Paracord - 2
4 lb monofilament fishing line - 2
0.065" trimmer string - 3
10 lb braided fishing line - 1.5
Denim - 2.5
Cloth - 2.5
Tissue - 2
Felt - 0
Cardboard - 3
Plastic bag - 2
Padded envelope - 2.5
Webbing - 2.5
Zip tie - 3
Nylon rope - 2.5
Stranded copper wire - 3
18 awg copper wire - 3
Plastic container - 3
Rubber ball - 3
Leather belt - 2.5
Cutting out simple pattern on paper - 3
Ergonomics - 3Total - 57.5/72
Scoring:
Effectively cuts material with minimal effort = 3
Requires an extra snip or some extra effort = 2.5
Will cut material, but requires holding material taunt or finding sweet spot on scissors = 2
Scissors tends to gnaw through material rather than cut cleanly - 1.5
Will cut material roughly and with great effort - 1
May be able to cut material, but not worth the effort - 0.5
Can not cut material - 0I had to cut near the tips for finer materials (last 1/4th of scissors). That is the only section where the edges meet. Otherwise, they perform well. Nice handles that, while maybe a bit bulky for keychain tool, felt good in my hand and allowed me to generate power.
-
Leatherman S4

Thread - 3
Mason cord - 3
Jute - 2.5
550 Paracord - 2
4 lb monofilament fishing line - 3
0.065" trimmer string - 3
10 lb braided fishing line - 3
Denim - 3
Cloth - 3
Tissue - 3
Felt - 3
Cardboard - 3
Plastic bag - 3
Padded envelope - 3
Webbing - 3
Zip tie - 3
Nylon rope - 2
Stranded copper wire - 3
18 awg copper wire - 3
Plastic container - 3
Rubber ball - 3
Leather belt - 2.5
Cutting out simple pattern on paper - 3
Ergonomics - 3Total - 69/72
Scoring:
Effectively cuts material with minimal effort = 3
Requires an extra snip or some extra effort = 2.5
Will cut material, but requires holding material taunt or finding sweet spot on scissors = 2
Scissors tends to gnaw through material rather than cut cleanly - 1.5
Will cut material roughly and with great effort - 1
May be able to cut material, but not worth the effort - 0.5
Can not cut material - 0Cuts better towards the tips than the pivot. It does cut very well if you stay in the sweet spot.
-
SOG Snippet

Thread - 3
Mason cord - 3
Jute - 3
550 Paracord - 2
4 lb monofilament fishing line - 3
0.065" trimmer string - 3
10 lb braided fishing line - 3
Denim - 3
Cloth - 3
Tissue - 3
Felt - 3
Cardboard - 3
Plastic bag - 3
Padded envelope - 3
Webbing - 2.5
Zip tie - 3
Nylon rope - 2.5
Stranded copper wire - 3
18 awg copper wire - 3
Plastic container - 3
Rubber ball - 3
Leather belt - 0
Cutting out simple pattern on paper - 3
Ergonomics - 1Total - 65/72
Scoring:
Effectively cuts material with minimal effort = 3
Requires an extra snip or some extra effort = 2.5
Will cut material, but requires holding material taunt or finding sweet spot on scissors = 2
Scissors tends to gnaw through material rather than cut cleanly - 1.5
Will cut material roughly and with great effort - 1
May be able to cut material, but not worth the effort - 0.5
Can not cut material - 0The Snippet does not have a spring for opening the scissors. Instead, it has a couple of outer handles that let the tool operate in the manner typical scissors do. Overall, the Snippet cuts well. But it is by far the least comfortable of all the scissors MTs that I have used.
-
Great thread Adam.

Surprised to see a notable difference between your Micra and Squirt. I know they're not actually the same scissor head but I didn't think there was a practical difference. Could age and wear be a factor?
-
@Gareth said:
Great thread Adam.
Surprised to see a notable difference between your Micra and Squirt. I know they're not actually the same scissor head but I didn't think there was a practical difference. Could age and wear be a factor?
Thanks Gareth :D
Well, the Micra is new and the S4 is like new, so the difference isn't due to age and wear.
Some of the difference can probably be attributed to variances in manufactoring. If several Micras were tested, some of them may perform better then the one I have.
-
Any chance of you (or anyone) graphing the results one day?
-
@Syncop8r said:
Any chance of you (or anyone) graphing the results one day?Yes. Here is a bar graph of the scissors I have tested so far:
📎 Scissors chart.pdf

-

I was thinking of the individual scores too. But that would be a lot of work.
-
Well, the Micra is new and the S4 is like new, so the difference isn't due to age and wear.
Some of the difference can probably be attributed to variances in manufactoring. If several Micras were tested, some of them may perform better then the one I have.

Yeah, sample size of one should always be taken into consideration but the test is still valid.

-
This is awesome! Great work Adam. Thanks for doing this

I see the difference between my Micra and my Style CS too here.
However, the Micra was a bit loose at the pivot.
I peened it tighter and it's better since. -
@Gareth said:
Great thread Adam.
Surprised to see a notable difference between your Micra and Squirt. I know they're not actually the same scissor head but I didn't think there was a practical difference. Could age and wear be a factor?
My Micra matches the ratings here, and it's old but barely used. My Craftsman tool outperforms it handily. I have a SOG crosscut 2 and a Schrade tough chip, and the Craftsman has better scissors than either. Though the cross-cut has compound leverage which means those scissors will go through a lot thicker stuff a lot more easily. But for paracord and such the Craftsman tool I have is unbeatable.
Charles.
-
My Micra is pretty good, until I almost ruined it when I tried to mod it. Thankfully I was able to fix it with the loki wrenches. Thanks again, loki.

Nice work, Adam. I appreciate the shout-out and the fact that you used so many materials.

-
I'd be interested in the results of some full size MT's. Great work!
-
Great review of several different tools
I use scissors quite a and usually just rely on SAK scissors but I do have a few of these tools as well and keep a Micra close by at home and a Squirt S4 in my work backpack 
Glad to see so many material and the chart you made is also helpful when comparing all the data together

-
Thanks guys!
I will try to get some more reviews/results out soon. I do plan to include full size MTs also. I have a decent amount of them to try out as well as some more mini scissors based MTs and some mini MTs that include scissors. Hopefully the list will eventually include Surge and Wave scissors.
Also, I will try to relearn some things I use to know how to do with LibreOffice and make some better charts.
-
I might be dreaming here
, but is there a way of having an interactive chart where you pick one or two criteria and it graphs them? Kinda like the "Compare" function some manufacturer's websites have but with graded values rather than yes/no. 
-
I will look into it. It may prove to be beyond my abilities, but I can see the utility of such a function and so I will try to do it.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

