How hard is it take apart and reassemble a SAK?
-
Yep - I am with the others - Do it yourself - It's great fun and not too hard -
Although you have to be careful - And I gotta say it took me forever :o
But you can get exactly what you want - And feel very proud of yourself afterwards.As Mags said lots of how to guides in the mods section
Hopefully you can harverst the bushings from the donor knife??
I got the brass rods from a model/crafting shop - You know - The ones that sell model trains and Airfix kits (do they still exist) etc etc - But metal suppliers may also sell them - But may not do retail quantities.BTW - What is your planned toolset? ???
-
@Huntsman said:
Hopefully you can harverst the bushings from the donor knife??I hope so... but I also discovered that I might have another option. Based on this post the 91 uses 2.5 for the outer and 2.25 for the one of the inner pins (the other inner doesn't have a collar). In the end I'm hoping to make two knives. That means I need:
8 x 2.5 collars
4 x 2.25 collarsNow, According to the same post 84mm knives use 2.2 for all pins. So if I get one set of collars for an 84mm, that will cover two knives plus some spares if I make a mistake. Likewise according to this post the 111mm with a slider lock uses 2.5mm for all the pins. So if I order two sets of those I'll end up with 12 collars, again more than enough for two knives.
I'm first gonna try my hand as drilling out an older knife and see if I can save the collars... if so then I don't have to buy. But if not I have options.
BTW - What is your planned toolset? ???
Still deciding that. But my working plan right now, as I said, is two knives, and I'm going to EDC both if this works out. Right now I carry a big knife so two medium won't be an issue and I like the concept of having two different tool sets that will compliment each either. For example right now I know that one of the two will have the bit driver and a magnifying lens. The other will have the pliers. Being able to have a screwdriver and a pliers in different tools just makes sense, ya know?
The other other thing I have "confirmed" in my head so far is that one will have a blade and the other a serrated blade.
-
Okay, so I've ordered my new brass rods, and I've got my first draft of tool sets for the two knives. I've also decided I'm going to do one in Red Scales because, that's traditional. The other will be in Blue scales. So:
Red:
Lg Blade - Sm Blade - Corkscrew
Metal Saw[ - - Chisel
Scissors - - Hook
Fish Scaller &Wood Saw - -
Pliers - -Blue:
Lg Serrated Blade - ? ??? ? - Corkscrew
Magnifying lens - Phillips Screw Driver -
Bit Driver - Bit Holder -
Large SD/Bottle Opener - Small SD/Can Openner - ReamerI have to do some final measurements when I have some time with my calipers instead of just eyeballing it, but I think this should produce pretty similar thick SAKs. If I need to pad one out a little larger I might look at adding a layer... we'll see.
My one unknown right now is what to pair with my serrated blade. I know I can but the combo tool or another small blade, but I'd like like to reduce redundancy if possible. Ideally I'd like to put the watchmaker took here as that's a bit solid tool for prying things open. I know that this will fit in with the big blade, but I don't know if it will in with the corkscrew as a back tool.
-
The watch case opener is usually on an 84mm model - Not sure if pin sizes are the same - And of course it doe feature on the XX 91mm models
But I would think you would not have a problem with the CS - And you can always do a bit of filing if necessary
But nice and unusual choice of tool!You'll have to name your models of course - My suggestions .....
The Closed SwissChamp and the Cyber ExplorerWhy the 'closed' SwissChamp? ??? .... No openers of course! ;) :D
-
@Huntsman said:
The watch case opener is usually on an 84mm model - Not sure if pin sizes are the same - And of course it doe feature on the XX 91mm modelsMy main donor knife is going to actually be a custom 91 SAK I had someone else make for me MANY years ago (like probably 20+ years ago). It has a serrated blade and the watch opener, but not with the corkscrew on the back so I'll be okay on the pin size. I can't honestly remember if the guy who made it modded an 84mm or if he or I got ahold of 91mm watch opener.
The donor I stopped EDCing quite a while back because it started getting dirty, worn and I damaged a few of the tools. Still it'll make a worth donor because it has virtually everything I'll need.
But nice and unusual choice of tool!
The goal here (I think I already stated it but because I love to hear myself
talk... er, I mean type) is to have the two compliment each other. There are times when it would have been so handy to have the pliers to hold a nut in one hand while screwing it with the other. Or using the Mag Glass while trying to grab something small with the pliers or cut it with the scissors.You'll have to name your models of course - My suggestions .....
The Closed SwissChamp and the Cyber Explorer - Why the 'closed' SwissChamp? ??? .... No openers of course! ;) :DOh geez... I hadn't thought about that yet. My old custom knife's name sort of fell into my lap. I had it made right around the time that the first duo core CPUs were coming out and it was a cybertool with two main knives. So, it was the Cybertool Core Duo.
Hmm... I actually really like CyberExplorer as it does combine a lot of features of both the Cyber.
Not wild about the Closed SwissChamp. Maybe... OutdoorMechanic? I think it also combines a lot of tools from the Outdoorsman (original and 'new') as well as the Mechanic. The Mechanic also has sentimental value for me as it was my first ever EDC. -
I've started dismantling my donor knives... One of which is an old and crusty Huntsman. I just posted a picture of it in the exploded/dismantled knives thread.
Two questions as I move towards the assembly stage:
-
How important at the different types of liners? Just in my knives alone I see all kinds of different styles and types and more online. How critical is it that I get these right?
-
Any recommendations on cleaning these parts, especially the liners, before assembly? Would I just trying sanding them a bit to clean off any caked on or light corrosion?
-
-
Hey RR,
I am no expert - But I would say:
-
Not too important - Apart from the obvious ones - ie Corkscrew liner and to make sure you can always access the nail nicks
-
Yes I use a very fine grit sandpaper, then a lightly oiled rag!
-
-
Best of luck
,,
I first had a custom done by a member, but then I did two others by myself, the one piece of advice I can give you is just be patient! It can be tricky but just take your time,
JR -
Progress update: I've taken apart all my donor knives. I had an old huntsman plus my original custom knife I had made more than a decade ago. Unfortunately I found a few problems in that process. Specifically, the scissors did not have the correct spring and the modder modified the hook to work with the wrong spring. It also appears that my metal saw was modified a bit because it too uses a different spring than I was expecting. Finally, I only had one key ring attachment and I wanted a key ring on both... so I went eBay shopping.
I found a cheap used Mountaineer off ebay and that supplied me with the the correct spring for the scissor and an unmodified hook. It also has a complete metal saw... no chisel, but I can live with that. Plus this one had the spring for the opener with the keyring on it, so that fills all my needs! That arrived yesterday and I look it apart last night.
I've also clean a number of the liners with sandpaper and sanding pads...
Last, I've finalized my tool layout. I've love to hear any opinions or thoughts on if I'm making a mistake with this order of tools at all.

Not too bad with them only being slightly over a mm apart in terms of width. Part of me is trying to figure out a way to get them even closer. The obvious solution is to add another liner on the Blue knife, but that seem silly to do just to make it a little wider. I've also considered adding the spatula, but this wouldn't be a tool I used extensive and, <u>more importantly</u>, I do not want to spend the money to buy an expensive SAK *just *to harvest the spatula from it.
-
You could get them to 0.48mm difference by swapping the pliers and the magnifier layers between tools...

-
@RedRamage said:
figure out a way to get them even closer.What if you move the file from its current location, placing it between the pliers and saw? That would let you drop a liner, as you can have the file/saw/scaler with no liners in between, and you'd be at 24.29mm for Red, only 0.3mm difference. At that point sand 0.1mm off each of Red's 3 internal liners and they'd be exactly the same thickness.
One other question - why Corkscrew on both, rather than Phillips on one of them? Is it to carry two different micro drivers?
-
@TazzieRob said:
You could get them to 0.48mm difference by swapping the pliers and the magnifier layers between tools...
I could, but I very specifically want the pliers on a different knife from the screw drivers. The idea is to be able to hold a nut with the pliers while turning a screw with the other knife. So I'm starting with the "rule" that all drivers are on one and the pliers on the other.
-
@Adreaver said:
What if you move the file from its current location, placing it between the pliers and saw? That would let you drop a liner, as you can have the file/saw/scaler with no liners in between, and you'd be at 24.29mm for Red, only 0.3mm difference. At that point sand 0.1mm off each of Red's 3 internal liners and they'd be exactly the same thickness.Interesting thought... I'll admit I'm not I don't know enough about the reason for liners to know if this is a good idea or not. I do know that Victorinox has knives with the wood saw and fish scaler without a liner in between, but I'm not sure if they have any with the metal, wood, and fish all together without a liner. I also know that they have a knives with the an arrangement of *Liner *- Metal - *Liner *- Wood - Fish - Liner. I would seem that Victorinox thinks there needs to be a liner in there. I'm just copying them.
One other question - why Corkscrew on both, rather than Phillips on one of them? Is it to carry two different micro drivers?
Exactly this reason. I did consider the Philips instead of the cork, but I already have the inline Philips which I think is a better big Philips driver. I know I could replace the inline Philips with a lite, but I've never been a big fan of those lights and when I need a light I've got my phone's light I can use... plus I might add a mini flashlight to my edc too.
-
Update: I'm part-way finished. I ran into some issues multiple times, but I've finally finished the first knife. I'm going to share a few things in my progress in case anyone else finds this thread later while they're considering making their own custom SAK.
First, taking a knife apart: Not having a drill press, I designed to use a dremel tool with a "ball bit." This worked well enough, but I had some issues. First, I wasn't very good at keeping the ball on the pin itself. I slipped more than a few times and gouged the aluminum liner... sometimes pretty bad. This wasn't catastrophic for me because I was was using a handful of different donor knives so had extra liners. Plus I'm using solid (ie, not translucent) scales so it'll hide my bigger sins. The bigger issue is that I also damaged a number of collars. I'd recommend NOT using the dremel like this unless you have decently steady hands. It works, but the risk of damage is pretty high.
Second, collars: Did you know there's a top and bottom to these? Okay, yeah... maybe this is obvious but never under estimate the stupidity of someone who knows just enough to get into trouble. Yeah, my first assembly attempt had these all on backwards. Oops. That was a waste. Just make sure you put them on the right way.
Third: man I suck with hammer: I've watch multiple videos on how to peen (pein?) pins and yet I just can't seem to do it well. I would highly recommend practicing one some old pins from your donor knives a lot. I think I ended up bending my pins multiple times. As I mentioned I did get one knife finished last night, but I know at least one of the 2.2mm pins is a little bent.
All in all it's not perfect, but it doesn't have to be. This isn't going to be a showcase knife... this will be an EDC so it's gonna get bumped up, banged around and it'll get some scars over time. So starting with a few imperfections isn't the end of the world. And I get to proudly say that I made it... well, assembled it at least. There's some satisfaction in being able to say that.
-
It's a great feeling to finally pop the scales back on to a finished mod, especially your first one!
You're right to be proud - you took a risk to make something unique to you and succeeded.With drilling out the pins, I'd recommend using a center punch to mark the centre of the pin and using a metal drill the same diameter as the pin to drill it out and it should provide a greater degree of accuracy.
Peening is just practice. And using the right tools. I used my Estwing claw hammer for my first effort and while it worked it wasn't nearly as good as the little ball peen I've been using subsequently. Also, patient and gentle tapping gets you there slowly but surely.
When can we see some pics?
-
Congratulations on the achievement. I agree it is something to be proud of and thanks for sharing your experience!
-
Well done RR -
And yes, for the first few times, there are going to be a few challenges along the way - it takes a little practice.
I am a bit of a DIYer myself and try to do most of the jobs around the house - The challenge on that, is that nearly everything you do, you are doing it for the first (and possibly only) time, compared to the tradey who only does that job, has done it a thousand times, and get it done in 1/10 the time it takes you!

So a bit like all these youtube vids of the experts building SAKs - They make it look so easy!! But it ain't
-
Sounds like you’re off to a great start!
@RedRamage said:
First, taking a knife apart: Not having a drill press, I designed to use a dremel tool with a "ball bit." This worked well enough, but I had some issues. First, I wasn't very good at keeping the ball on the pin itself. I slipped more than a few times and gouged the aluminum liner... sometimes pretty bad. This wasn't catastrophic for me because I was was using a handful of different donor knives so had extra liners. Plus I'm using solid (ie, not translucent) scales so it'll hide my bigger sins. The bigger issue is that I also damaged a number of collars. I'd recommend NOT using the dremel like this unless you have decently steady hands. It works, but the risk of damage is pretty high.I think the Dremel plunge router has the potential (along with a clamp or two) to function like a poor man’s drill press. Price is quite reasonable, especially if you already have the Dremel…
-
@magentus said:
Peening is just practice. And using the right tools. I used my Estwing claw hammer for my first effort and while it worked it wasn't nearly as good as the little ball peen I've been using subsequently. Also, patient and gentle tapping gets you there slowly but surely.Yeah, that's the part that causes me some issues! :D I'm not so good on the patience part. One of the problems I was running into was holding the pins while trying to do the initial peening. I have a small vice, but when I used it marred up the pins, so I wasn't happy with that, but obviously just holding them in my hand wasn't going to work either.
I finally hit upon a solution that mostly worked... I 3D printed two small blocks with a half circle cut out of of each that was a little too small for the pin. I think clamped those blocks around the pin and could really tighten up the vice on the blocks to put pressure on the pin with out digging into the brass.
This wasn't a perfect hold so the rod would slowly slip through the blocks as I peened, but I could get quite a number of taps in before I'd have to adjust the pin back up. This helped a lot with the process for me.
When can we see some pics?
Their coming. I'm gonna do a new thread with pics because I'm assembling a new EDC "pouch" with the knives and a few others things.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login